New Berlin Girl Pulled from Brookfield Pool Has Died
An 8-year-old girl found unconscious and unresponsive in Wirth Aquatic Center died Wednesday at Children's Hospital of Wisconsin, according to the Waukesha County Medical Examiner's office.
An 8-year-old New Berlin girl pulled from Brookfield's Wirth Pool while on a summer field trip has died, according to the Waukesha County Medical Examiner's office.
The girl, whose identity was not released, died at Children's Hospital of Wisconsin, where she has remained since being rushed there July 3 after she was pulled unconscious and not breathing from a 4-foot-deep area of the pool.
She was visiting Wirth pool with about 75 other youth in New Berlin's Summer Playground program, which travels to Wirth every Tuesday afternoon to swim.
Lifeguards and a North Shore emergency medical technician who was swimming at Wirth that afternoon tried to revive her with CPR and a defibrillator before Brookfield paramedics arrived and took over, eventually taking her to Children's Hospital.
New Berlin's group did not return to Wirth this week and also will not be there July 17, and is evaluating how to handle its swim programming for the rest of the summer, New Berlin Park and Recreation Director Mark Schroeder told Patch Thursday morning, at which time he was not aware of the girl's death. He could not be immediately reached late Thursday.
Mayor offers 'heartfelt sympathy'
Brookfield Mayor Steve Ponto and Brookfield Park and Recreation Director Bill Kolstad expressed condolences to the family and all involved.
"This was a tragic accident and our heartfelt sympathy and condolences go to the family," Ponto said. "All of us here at City Hall have had this young girl and her family in all of our hearts and prayers."
Kolstad said: "All of us are deeply saddened by the loss. There is nobody who was involved in this incident who hasn’t been emotionally impacted. Our hearts and prayers go out to the family."
Why the girl, who was on her first park and recreation trip to Wirth Park, fell unconscious in the pool was unknown. Police said they were still investigating. The medical examiner's office conducted an autopsy Thursday but the exact cause of death was not available.
Both Kolstad and Schroeder, in his earlier interview Thursday, each said there was proper supervision by their respective pool and park and recreation staff.
"We haven’t been provided any information by the police department that would lead us to conclude that there have been issues with types of procedures," Kolstad said. "We’re extreme proud of our aquatic staff and their response to the tragedy."
Counselors were made available to lifeguards who Kolstad said decided they wanted to return to their chairs and posts the next day, which was the extremely hot Fourth of July holiday.
Directors: proper supervision provided
Schroeder said there were 77 youth on the field trip and 12 park and recreation staff members, for a ratio of about 6 to 1.
"We did the things that we normally would do," he said. "We had the normal number of chaperones and the typical number of campers or kids from the playground that were there.
"We make sure that they’re safely from the bus into the pool environment and our people are both in the water on the deck, wherever the kids may be at that particular event. So there was nothing different from our perspective," Schroeder said.
"We certainly are looking at everything we did and is there a way to improve," he said. "I continue to pride ourselves with what we do for a safety program but we wouldn't be doing our due dilligence if we weren't reviewing things."
Schroeder said his department has taken field trips to Wirth Park for many years and his staff "have always thought very highly of that (Brookfield) department and the way they do things."
Parents of other children enrolled in the New Berlin summer program "have been wonderful," Schroeder said. They have expressed concern for the girl's family and staff and have told staff they continue to feel safe bringing their children to the program.
"It’s certainly most traumatic for the family of the young girl," Schroeder said, but added: "Our staff has taken it hard because they get to know all of their kids on a pretty good basis throughout the summer."
The group has not gone swimming, however, and it is unknown if it will resume Wirth Park trips or several other planned trips yet this summer to places such as Country Springs Water Park.
DICK STEINBERG
6:07 pm on Thursday, July 12, 2012
the publicity over this sad event is not good for the City of Brookfield.
Criba
11:52 am on Friday, July 13, 2012
Poor poor Brookfields bad publicity. This is what your contributions are regarding such a sad event?
Mean while, a family is grieving over the loss of a daughter, sister, granddaughter or niece. You are a schmuck, Dick!
DICK STEINBERG
5:57 pm on Sunday, July 15, 2012
to be clear, the bad publicity as expressed by the press, makes us look like we have no security measures to protect the swimmers. of course, the child is the sad event.
Jane Pipia
6:22 pm on Thursday, July 12, 2012
God bless that little girl and her family.
Michelle
9:07 pm on Thursday, July 12, 2012
How awful... Praying for the family ... God bless
Common Sense
9:26 pm on Thursday, July 12, 2012
Sending prayers for the family.
Jake brown
11:30 pm on Thursday, July 12, 2012
They should continue their trips after reviewing their procedures and making any improvements they can. Wish the autopsy could tell why she lost consciousness before going under the water. Deepest sympathy to her family, friends and the youth workers who felt close to her.
Kbg516
7:23 am on Friday, July 13, 2012
Its not bad publicity for Brookfield ...Its been reported that all procedures were properly executed with New Berlin and Brookfield. I'm deeply saddened that this family has sustained one of, if not the most horrific tragedy of our human existence.
Lynne Thomas
8:38 am on Friday, July 13, 2012
Nowhere does it say that she lost consciousness BEFORE going underwater - only that she was pulled from the pool unconscious. Regardless of the particulars of the situation, this was still a preventable death. Even if it's true that all existing procedures were properly followed, those procedures have now been proven inadequate and should be thoroughly reviewed and reevaluated.
Sandra Schultz
3:21 pm on Friday, July 13, 2012
The cause of death is unknown at this time which means she could have lost consciousness before going underwater, she could had a seizure, she could have become dizzy and disoriented from dehydration, there could be many cause and perhaps we will never exactly know. It is prudent to review safety procedures in these cases but it is not to say that the procedures were inadequate and/or that the death was preventable. We must caution ourselves and understand that sometimes bad things happen even under proper supervision and policy and I know that doesn't make anyone feel better during these horrific times of grief but until the investigation proves otherwise this is a horrible, tragic accident and any parent's worst nightmare. My heartfelt sympathies go out to this family and the those emotional impacted by this trauma.
thomdg
9:57 am on Saturday, July 14, 2012
As a physician who completes death certificates, I must comment. The cause of death would be likely be drowning, any condition described hypothetically above would be listed a contributing factor. This cause of death would be reported to the center for disease control, who would add this to their month morbidity and mortality report as a drowning. (This heat wave has resulted in a record number of drownings nationally this summer) The CDC considers all drowning to be a preventable death.
In the past, car accidents were a common cause of tragic death. Certainly, many people died in a accident after suffering a seizure or heart attack. Thankfully, rather than attributing these deaths to the victims poor health, we expected more. The result, seat belts, air bags, and more people who walk away from car accidents rather than die from them .
Rena
11:42 pm on Saturday, July 14, 2012
This little girl was a close family friend. She will forever be missed. The "what if's" are behind us. This was a horrible accident. As a city and community we need to move forward and take whatever precautions are needed to prevent this situation from recurring. As a community, this family needs our prayers through this very difficult time.
sophia knox
10:30 am on Sunday, July 15, 2012
i go to new berlin park and reck and she was a friend of mine. we are all sad about her and we will have her in our prayers.
#Littledog
8:04 am on Thursday, July 19, 2012
Glad the doctor spoke up. All the speculation about, "well, she must have had an asthma attack, she must have bonked her head and went under water unconscious," are all events which could have been resolved (or at least she'd have a fighting chance) if the response time was quicker. The first time someone realized there was a problem was when she was floating. A little too late.
I'm not faulting the staff or life guards-I don't think a 6:1 ratio is adequate supervision for children in such a large, crowded pool. There also need to be more lifeguards. I feel so much safer swimming at Hoyt Pool in Tosa because there are lifeguards about every 3 feet! The pool is much smaller and they limit their capacity before it gets over-crowded. The kids have to pass a swimming test to swim in 4 feet or deeper; they are given a password they have to tell the lifeguards every time they go back to the pool. Sometimes kids crack the password code (to give to their friends who might not have passed the swim test) and then the lifeguards re-test all the kids all over again. Hoyt also has a rule where there must be 1 caregiver for every 4 kids (not 6!)
Accidents do happen, but lessons can be learned from such a tragic death. I know this can happen anywhere, but as a mom, I've never felt very comfortable at Wirth pool.