Remember, you only are in the drawing for the $50 if you write your choice and why in the comments here!

My husband knows he has my heart, but the way to my stomach is definitely a steak and baked potato. Fleming's is the best in the style of an old-style steakhouse! <3

The bar at Mitchell's Fish Market is an ideal romantic escape. The drinks are delicious - they make a mean Cosmo. Combine that with a cozy corner spot, your honey and a plate of fresh oysters on the half shell and watch things heat up!

Flemings is definitely the most romantic spot. The lights are dimmed, the service very special, the steaks great. Unfortunately, it is also probably the most expensive Brookfield dining establishment but well worth it for special occasions. My husband and I celebrated our 50th wedding anniversary there with our children and grandchildren. Very special.

I'm going to throw in for one more favorite – PS23! The back room is quiet and a bit more intimate than the main dining room. The food and service are always great and the home grown vegetables (in season) are a delight. Best of all, you can scale the cost to your liking by selecting from different parts of the menu.

Bonefish Grill - cozy setting, impecable food, attention to detail. always feels like we are the only ones in the place even though they are full to the brim. and lets not forget the amazing martinis (blueberry being my fav or rasberry well i guess any would do)

Thanks, Samantha, for re-posting your Facebook comment here. http://www.facebook.com/BrookfieldWIPatch

I vote for NorthStar for their combination of decor, excellent seasonal menu, great wine list, expert unobtrusive service and cozy booths. Definitely a place where you can celebrate a special occasion or have a casual weekday meal.

We also like Jakes, which was left off this list.

My vote is for Mr. B's. The warm atmosphere and the exquisite service make for a special night.

My vote is for Mr. B's Steakhouse. My husband and I love the food and the restaurant is lovely inside as well. The service is top notch and they really make you feel welcome we love to go there to celebrate all of our special occasions.

You're making me hungry for a good steak! $50 for steak would be a great deal. Too bad I can't enter.

If you can picture a mild August night, candle lit table on the patio at Vino Cappuchino, maybe a wine flight Wednesday? I havent said a thing about the food yet. How about italian? Spaghetti al pesto? Nobody makes a pesto sauce at home with there spaghetti...they do here. How about eggplant parmesan? The food here is legit, and the service is just as good. Finish the night off with a slice of homeade cake. You dont need a chain restaurant to have a romantic date in Brookfield.

Mr.B's gets my vote. Whether you stop in for a drink, dine in the restaurant or visit the patio on a warm summer night ... the place is perfect for a couples night out. Plus, they have a great bar menu (burgers, steak sandwiches) which is also on the regular menu. I wish they were open for lunch during the year ... Not just December!

Olive Garden. They alway have great breadsticks and food! (And we have always had awesome service)

Flemings gets my vote. Nice decor, service, fantastic wines & STEAK. My wife & I celebrated Valentine's 2009 there and it was among the most memorable of our 20 together.

After taking a significant other on a date awhile back one evening to the Melting Pot in Brookfield, I have come to the conclusion that this is a unique and great place for a romantic time, plus enjoy tasty fondue choices.in multiple courses. The wine was splended and the wait staff was very friendly. Was a very memorable experience.

Bonefish Grill for me...the food is fantastic, they have a great drink selection (Winter Whiteberry yummy!) and I love the lighting and decor. Very warm & cozy for a romantic dinner.

I CHOSE HOOTERS THE GIRLS MAKE ME ROMANTIC MY GIRLFRIEND DOES'NT SHE'S FAT AND UGLY

This is much better than Menomonee Falls' contest. But then again Brookfield has everything including the best restaurants. Put me down for Mr. B's.

Cafe One24 is a great spot for a romantic dinner - the atmosphere and service are great, it's small, quiet, and the food and wine are fantastic.

For me it is Carrabbas. It isn't uptight, like Fleming's, but rather warm and cozy. The lighting is always dim which is refreshing having to be surrounded by God awful flourescents daily. Whether it is just my husband and I or we have our kids, it always seems to be romantic. The kids stay entertained by playing with pizza dough and hubby and I catch up over a 2-for-1 cocktail (that pleases the hubby:).

We really enjoy the Historic Red Mill. Great food, wonderful service, and a quiet atmosphere perfect for romantic dinners!

Jake's! Good old-fashioned steak dinner! And a great patio in summer too!

Mr. B's is by far the best choice....fantastic food & atmosphere.

Bonefish Grill for the great atmosphere, wonderful service and gluten free menu!

Mr. B's is by-far the most romantic place in town. The service is top-notch and the servers know when to leave a couple to themselves. Great job!

Who doesn't love the tableside guac and a zillion margarita flavors at Jose's!? Family friendly but still a nice crowd. This is as romantic as it gets for us with 3 teenagers at home!

The wife and I don't get to many expensive places so I would have to choose Olive Garden. Great food. Great service. Italian music!

Go to Tokyo Restaurant off Bluemound in Elm Grove and get a cozy booth. Then order the love boat for two and share it with your love one! YUM!

I always have a great time at Mitchels with my wife, food is great and the atmosphere is wonderful.

Jake's! Cozy old house turned into charming restaurant. Great steaks too!

I like the Melting Pot - you have privacy and chocolate fondue - how romantic!
Simple as that!

NorthStar Bistro is the place now that The Grove closed. It has cozy booths for our private conversations and wonderful food with great service. They have a nice selection of wines too! We often go there for our special occasions and they have daily specials as well. Never have been disappointed. Lunches are great too. We highly recommend it.

Vino Cappucino would be my romantic restaurant of choice. I love their fireplace along with a nice glass of merlot. Pretty much everything on their menu is delicious. A gift certificate would make a night at Vino Cappucino even more special. :)

While I don't normally recommend franchised restaurants I think that Carrabbas has a lot to offer. The wonderful menu filled with family favorite recipes. The atmosphere is quiet and relaxed. The lighting sets an amazing ambiance. This place wins me over. My husband and I have enjoyed a variety of the wines and favorite dishes.

I like Melting Pot, I love the fondue and the different courses! It's cozy, quiet and you can eat off of sticks!!!!

Mr. B's is not only THE place for romance, it is the yummy food that keeps us going back!

I like the Melting Pot's atmosphere. Dim/quiet. The seating seems private, and sharing fondue adds a level of intimacy to the dining experience.

By far our favorite Special Romantic Restaurant is Mr. B's The atmosphere is superb. The servers always make you feel like a VIP. And the food.... well there is nothing like a Mr B's Steak! It is a most special Restaurant.

1st Place: Melting Pot... in addition to being delicious, the concept just forces you to slow down and enjoy one another
2nd Place: Parkside 23
Haven't been to Flemings, I have a hunch that would be up there too.
Also have to say that we like Jake's in Pewaukee a lot too.

Mr. B's steakhouse! Why? Give your man a cut of meat from this establishment and you will soon discover how romantic he can be! Food that good is full of romance!

We have a winner. Thanks to each and EVERY one of you who participated. Sorry we can't shower you all with certificates! ---> http://brookfield-wi.patch.com/articles/it-s-a-tie-mr-b-s-and-bonefish-grill-named-most-romantic-brookfield-restaurant