Brookfield Officials Grapple with Opposition to Proposed Mosque

City leaders uncertain how to handle residents' concerns about Islam and are consulting with a civil rights attorney to get some advice on controversial issue.

With some residents raising concerns about the cultural influence of a , city officials are grappling with how to handle a public dialogue that Mayor Steven Ponto said should focus on the building itself rather than the religion.

"We’re really reviewing a building; we’re not reviewing a religion," Ponto said. "I don’t think anyone wants a government to start reviewing a religion."

City officials must consider the legal implications of allowing religious concerns into the conversation, as they decide whether to grant the Islamic Society of Milwaukee a conditional-use permit for their proposal. Federal laws such as the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act prohibit zoning decisions that limit the free exercise of religion.

"I think the way that federal law and the federal constitution apply is that there is freedom of religion, and we respect that," Ponto said. "The focus of our attention should be on the building issues related to sewers, stormwater and traffic."

Looking for clear legal standards, Alderman Scott Berg said the city is conferring with Gregg Gunta, an attorney who has represented several other cities in federal civil rights cases.

Opposition Surfaces on Several Fronts

The Islamic Society wants to build the mosque at 16650 and 16730 W. Pheasant Dr., a short distance northeast of the Calhoun Road-North Avenue intersection.  The group hopes to eventually expand the facility to serve about 350 congregants.

While many residents have fears about the mosque bringing religious extremists and even ties to terrorism, some opponents are keeping their public criticism to building issues, and particularly traffic, to build a stronger case against the proposal.

"A mosque is a Trojan Horse in a community. Muslims have not come to integrate but to dominate."

Thus even if the city has legal guidance to limit areas of consideration, Berg said it could be hard to judge true public opinion if residents with religious concerns voice their disapproval under the guise of traffic concerns. 

"The really difficult thing is when someone comes up and says, 'I think the mosque will generate too much traffic (wink-wink, nudge-nudge),'" Berg said. "That’s the judgment we will have to make."

At the same time, many residents have not backed off the religious front.

Earlier this month, resident Dave Glasgow petitioned aldermen by email to reject the mosque proposal on religious grounds.

"As a resident of Brookfield since 1970, I am greatly troubled by this development and am respectfully asking that you reject the proposal on the grounds that the ideology of Islam is incompatible with western culture, our Judeo-Christian foundation, and universally accepted human values of freedom, liberty, and justice," Glasgow wrote. 

"A mosque is a Trojan Horse in a community," Glasgow continued. "Muslims have not come to integrate but to dominate."

On Saturday, VCY America, which operates Christian radio programming, is holding a rally at the Waukesha County Expo Center titled, "The Growing Threat of Islam." Berg said the organization invited all Brookfield aldermen to the event, with reserved front row seats for them, though it's unclear whether the group will specifically address the Brookfield mosque proposal.

"I have no intention of going there because I believe their points are probably not true; and even if they are true, they are not relevant," Berg said.

More Meetings on Tap

The city will hold a public information meeting on the proposed mosque May 2 at 6:30 p.m. in the courtroom of the at 2100 N. Calhoun Rd. Officials will be available to answer questions and will give a presentation at 7 p.m.

A public hearing on the proposal is scheduled for May 7, with the time and location to be announced.

"We get an issue of that magnitude once every 10 years," Berg said. "This is just going to be a lightening rod."

Justin April 13, 2012 at 06:42 PM
Dave Glasgow is a bigot. I like how he says, " that the ideology of Islam is incompatible with western culture, our Judeo-Christian foundation, and universally accepted human values of freedom". Dave I think you need to look up the definition of freedom. These people deserve to have a place to worship like you and I do.
Katie Lynn Weiss April 17, 2012 at 03:38 PM
I've lived in Brookfield since 1997, and I'm troubled by all the bigots who occupy my city; I respectfully ask that they leave, as they are incompatible with reason and logic. Might I add, the United States of America was founded on RELIGIOUS FREEDOM!
Kathryn April 17, 2012 at 09:15 PM
I am beyond disappointed and ashamed with my hometown. I have lived in Brookfield since I was born in 1992. I can't even express how appalled I was as I read this article and heard about this current debate. First of all, this is a mosque for Muslims. I am white, I could be Muslim if I wanted to be. Muslim is a religion and not a race in anyway. There is no reason to assume any sort of ties to terrorism or extremism. The fact that someone is going as far to say that this mosque is a "Trojan Horse" in a community is absolutely ridiculous. You can't possibly believe that this building for religion practice purposes is going to be used as an invasion tactic to dominate our city. It makes me incredibly sad that people are this naive and ignorant. Step outside of the Brookfield white-bread bubble and realize that different culture and religion is a part of life. There is no reason that these people should not be able to have a place to practice their religious beliefs and basic religion freedom. Dave Glasgow, to say that this proposal should be rejected due to its incompatibility with "universally accepted human values of freedom, liberty and, justice" is so wrong. You clearly need to reevaluate your definition of freedom and the basic values our country was founded on.
Sad Face April 23, 2012 at 03:49 AM
If the concern is really about traffic they should be studying the Mosque on 13th and Layton. I'll bet that intersection was busier than the one in Brookfield even before the Mosque. The people are already worshiping here whether or not we build a new place for them. It is also sad that a town of generally wealthy people are so uncharitable.
bob July 12, 2012 at 02:39 AM
sad to see this kind of bigotry right here in Wisconsin, if there are Muslims in brook field or in the area, they have every right to worship like everyone else! Last time I checked, freedom of religion was in the constitution


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »